Finding the right pacifier for a breastfed baby can be a little tricky. You’re looking for something that’ll calm your little one down at the pace of breastfeeding, not hinder it. There are pacifiers that are made to resemble the texture of a nursing nipple to avoid nipple confusion and keep baby calm and happy. In this guide, we’ll share the best pacifiers for breastfed babies that provide the optimal level of comfort and safety and are safe for breastfeeding.
1. Nanobebe Pacifiers 0-3 month -Grey, 2-pack.
If you’re on the hunt for the best pacifiers for breastfed babies, you can’t go wrong with the Nanobebe Baby Pacifiers, which are made with a baby’s health and comfort in mind. Designed for breast-fed babies, the BPA-free Complete Silicone Baby Bottle is the next best thing to mom. This nipple confusion solution makes them a hit with new moms and dads.
Key Features:
- 100% Soft Silicone – For a soft and familiar feel that’s gentle in baby’s mouth and close to a natural feel.
- Ergonomic Design: Fits the natural shape of a baby’s face, nose, and chin.
- Our Safe One-Piece Construction: Keeps your baby free of hard edges and loose parts. Seamless design recommended by pediatricians. Meets American Academy of Pediatrics Guidelines.
- BPA & Phthalate Free: Constructed of baby-safe materials for peace of mind.
- Easy to Clean: Dishwasher safe, sterilizer-safe and a one-piece design.
- Stage 2 Also Available: The new Flexy Active Pacifier is great on the go, and designed for even better airflow and lighter weight.
Pros:
- Ideal for breastfed babies – No nipple confusion.
- A snug, comfortable fit for preemies.
- Recommended by: pediatricians Design.
- Easy to sterilize and clean.
- One Piece durable, silicone construction is easy to clean and is top rack dishwasher safe.
- Awesome addition to any baby registry.
Cons:
- Comes only in a number of colors like gray.
- Could be slightly small once baby is out of 3 months plus size.
If you want the best pacifiers for breastfed newborns, the Nanobebe Baby Pacifiers are the solution. Featuring a baby-first design with safe and soft materials. These natural shaped dummies offer comfort as well as support for healthy oral development. Adored by moms and babies, the award-winning pacifier set gives newborns a must-have accessory, particularly if they are breastfed.
2. Smily Mia Penguin Baby Teething Toy–Light Blue (0-6 Months).
If you’re on the hunt for the best pacifiers for breastfed babies, the Smily Mia Penguin Teething Toy is a top teething relief and comfort choice. Designed with baby in mind for ages 0 – 6 months, this teether not only works to relax baby’s grip and ease teething discomfort, but it also acts as a pacifier, offering a calming sensation that closely resembles natural breastfeeding—ideal for babies who don’t take a traditional pacifier.
Key Features:
- Easy Grip for Sucking & Teething: Promotes suction, with gentle, skin-like texture of our nipple; It helps to ease the transition between breast and baby bottle; Designed to relieve teething discomfort.
- Breastfed Baby Friendly: Good for breastfed baby who refuses regular pacifiers. The familiar shape allows you to find the perfect fit for your child’s needs.
- Safe Material: BPA free, phthalate free and toxin free material. No odor, no fumes, no chemicals, and no choking fumes.
- Ergonomics Penguin Design: The teether is snug and stay in babies’ hand, no hazard of choking and very pleasant to babies.
- Developmental Support: It features baby teething on one of the ears with raised ridges and is easy to hold.
- Travel Friendly & Machine Washable: Dishwasher safe and compact enough to fit in diaper bags, car seats or attach to strollers for on-the-go convenience.
Pros:
- Ideal for breastfed babies because they are more like the bottle nipple.
- Serves as both a teether and pacifier.
- Safety, nontoxic and ergonomic design.
- Promotes early oral and jaw development.
- Dishwasher and freezer safe.
- Lightweight and portable.
Cons:
- Only offered in a handful of colors, such as light blue.
- Interest may wane in some babies as they grow beyond 6 months.
For those parents looking for the best pacifier shape for breastfed babies, you need to try Smily Mia Penguin Teething Toy, you won’t regret it. It will not only relieve the teething pain but will help the child to emulate mother’s nursing to moisten the bumps and prove calming and familiar! Safe, functional and developmentally appropriate. This smart little penguin is not just a teether, it’s a best friend for both babies and moms.
3. NUK Timeless Comfort Pacifiers, (0-6 Months), 5-Pack, Color May Vary.
When considering which pacifiers are best for breastfed babies, it all comes down to comfort, safety, and a natural feel. The NUK Timeless Comfy Pacifier hits all those marks with a smart oval shape which mimics the shape of mom’s nipple during breastfeeding. It also fits the baby’s mouth the way a breast does. It makes the perfect natural shape to support healthy oral development. This helps prevent nipple confusion so that you can baby feed baby with ease.
Key Features:
- Breast-Like Nipple Shape: This nipple is made to feel like your breast, and encourages your baby to latch on like the first stage of breastfeeding.
- Orthodontic Fit: Promotes proper oral development by naturally fitting the baby’s palate.
- Soft, 100% Medical-Grade Silicone: Beads are soft on baby’s skin and won’t scratch when baby is wearing them.
- Shield in Heart-Shape: Soft particularly on baby’s nose and helps to breathe freely.
- For Newborns: Sized just right for 0–6 months and designed with them in mind.
- Manufactured in the USA: High- quality products manufactured in the USA.
Pros:
- Perfect for breastfed babies with the natural nipple shape.
- Encourages proper oral development with an orthodontic design.
- Crafted from body-safe medical-grade silicone.
- Ventilation - Ergonomic shield for a comfortable and extended wear.
- 5-pack-pacifier Value and quality at an affordable price.
- Trusted quality, made in the USA.
Cons:
- If not in a clean container, silicone is likely to pick up dust and lint.
- Parents are provided with the option of a handle or loop for easy grip.
If you want the best pacifier for breastfed baby, the NUK Timeless Comfy Pacifier is a top pick. The breast like shape, promotes optimal development while the soft, natural shape and feel of the nipple make it easy for baby to combine breast and bottle feeding. And with our convenient 5-pack, you will never be without a pacifier when your baby needs one.
4. Dr. Brown’s HappyPaci 100% Silicone Pacifier, 0 – 6 month, Blue, 3 Count.
When it comes to the best pacifiers for breastfed babies, comfort and familiarity are top of mind. Dr. Brown’s HappyPaci is developed to provide the ultimate soothing experience for baby, with durable, ultra-soft silicone and an easily replaceable orthodontic shape nipple. Shaped like a bottle nipple and made from soft, durable silicone, it is comfortable for baby to latch onto and enjoy without the confusion.
Key Features:
- Similar Nipple Shape: Mimics Dr. Brown’s bottle nipples for more easy of transition for baby from breast to bottle.
- 100% Silicone: Soothing on tender gums, making it perfect for early teethers.
- Contoured Shield Design: Unique butterfly shaped shield curves away from baby’s face for comfort and provides room for baby’s nose and cheeks.
- Breathable and Comfortable: Air holes on the shield provides natural air, and will not irritate the skin.
- Open Back Soother: Open back design lets parents easily feel baby’s heartbeat through the soother for greater comfort and bonding.
- Easy to clean, one-piece design prevents trapped moisture, dishwasher and sterilizer safe.
Pros:
- Designed to be most like mom, the NaturalWave slow-flow nipple encourages baby’s intuitive latching response and is the accepted 2017 best bottle for breastfed babies
- Safe and durable — these soft, medical-grade silicone bristles are dishwasher safe for an easy clean.
- Vented shield minimizes skin irritation
- Soft, comfortable and warm on newborn babies
- Includes soothing, gender-neutral colors in a value 3-pack
- Easy to clean and sterilize
Cons:
- Might not work as well with babies who haven’t used Dr. Brown’s bottles.
- No handle, or ring to attach to pacifier clips.
For parents looking for the best pacifiers for breastfed baby, the Dr. Brown’s HappyPaci is a cute, well-designed choice. With a breast-like nipple shape, gentle silicone body and skin-soothing shield, this soother is perfect for calming fussier babes without interfering with feeding time. Saves you thousands of thumb-sucking lessons, and thumb sucking is something a child shouldn’t disregard; Stop thumb-sucking before it starts!Easy to use; Easy to clean; Easy to love; This is a must-have pacifier in every new born and newborn baby care kit.
5. BIBS Natural Rubber Baby Pacifiers – Sage/Cloud (0-6 Months, 2-Pack).
When seeking the best pacifiers for breastfed babies, you want something made of natural or soft materials that offers comfort and feels familiar. BIBS natural rubber baby pacifiers not only look good, but they have a 40-year track record of traditional style that is the preferred choice of many mothers. These pacifiers are designed to closely resemble the shape of a mother’s nipple, help your baby suck naturally to complement breastfeeding, and include a case for easy transport.
Key Features:
- Natural Rubber Latex Nipple: Soothes and comforts with an orthodontic nipple that is soft and flexible and has an asymmetrical shape which closely resembles a mother’s nipple.
- Natural Shaped Nipple: Mimics mom as closely as possible while still allowing baby to use nipple of choice.
- Classic Danish Design: Simple, elegant look, available in six stunning color combinations.
- 100% BPA, PVC & Phthalate-Free: Constructed with safe, anti-microbial materials.
- Made in Denmark: The production facilities are located in Denmark – your assurance of the highest quality product that meets the strict European standards.
- Size 1 (0+ Months): Best newborn pacifier for breastfed, and available in other sizes for more age groups.
Pros:
- Perfect for breastfed babies because they are designed to be as close to natural as possible.
- Constructed of soft, natural rubber latex.
- Comes in fashionable and timeless colors like Sage and Cloud.
- Features Lightweight with ergonomic shield design.
- Premium quality—since 40 years made in Denmark.
- Comes in a convenient 2-pack.
Cons:
- Needs replacing every 4–6 weeks because the natural material will wear out sooner.
- Vulnerable to heat, sunlight and humidity – needs to be stored carefully.
Parents in search for pacifiers for breastfed babies can let their babies enjoy a natural BIBS Natural Rubber Pacifier. Their silky soft texture proves gentle on baby’s skin, minimising resistance whilst feeding, so babies are more content in between feeds, and you can be too. These are baby approved this amazing pacifier will make your baby so happy!
6. MAM Original Day & Night Pacifiers – 0–6 Months Value Pack (4 Pack), Sweet Pink/Orchid/Ivory.
It can be challenging to find a pacifier for breastfed babies that prioritizes comfort, safety, and breast-feeding compatibility. MAM Original Day & Night Pacifiers, These pacifiers are specially designed to meet baby’s oral care needs and Comfort baby through the night. With a silicone nipple and handy glow in the dark feature, these pacifiers make for a delightful combination of form and function.
Key Features:
- Silicone SkinSoft Nipple: BPA Free silicone nipple has a soft, skin-like texture that makes it easier for baby to transition from breast to bottle and back, as well as to reduce the risk of nipple confusion.
- Day & Night Convenience: These 2 glow-in-the-dark pacifiers work like a charm, making it simple to locate pacifiers in a low light room without having to wake your sleepy baby!
- Symmetrical orthodontic design: This pacifier’s design keeps your baby’s palate and gums even and well developed.
- Breathable Shield: Curved with wide openings to prevent skin irritation or moisture build up.
- Designed with Medical Experts: Adopts good health material, it touches your baby’s mouth area from a rubber angle baby pacifier.
- Babies Love It: Silky texture ensures that babies are loving it, they just can’t help it!
Pros:
- Ultra soft nipple mimics the feel of the breast for your baby’s enjoyment.
- Glows in the dark for a stress-free sleep with your baby.
- Symmetrical shape that fosters oral health.
- Breathable barrier helps guard against skin irritation.
- 4-pack with cute and cuddly colors.
- Safe for Everyday Use BPA- and BPS-free.
Cons:
- Some parents have said the glow feature diminishes after a short amount of time if not exposed to light.
- The symmetrical design won’t be ideal for all babies who take to a more traditional nipple shape
When it comes to the best pacifier for breastfed babies, the MAM Original Day & Night Pacifiers are a convenient and baby approved choice. From their soft, skin-like nipples to their glow-in-the-dark nighttime convenience. They’re made to soothe and comfort while promoting natural sucking for easy, seamless transitions between breast and bottle feeding. These pacifiers are a tried and tested by experts, due to their expert design, and high acceptance rate with babies.
7. Tommee Tippee - Fiesta Fun Time Baby Pacifier, BPA-free - Girl, 0-6 Months(4 Count).
The ideal pacifiers for breastfed babies are ones that are soft, light and simulates natural oral development without causing nipple confusion. The Tommee Tippee Ultra-Light Silicone Pacifier is a really good one on all fronts. This pacifier is the feather-light, orthodontic pacifier that’s ergonomically specially designed to adapt to the contours of a baby’s mouth, is a good Pacifier and user the baby safe material, it’s ideal for even the fussiest of babies.
Key Features:
- Ultra Lightweight Design: It’s one of the lightest pacifiers available so it’s easy for baby to keep in her mouth.
- Silicone nipple with SkinSoft textured surface for soothing aching gums; Perfect fit for baby’s mouth.
- Airflow-Optimized Shield – Curved and vented reduce irritation on skin, rashes, and perspiration.
- Comfort-Fit Shield: Soft and made to comfortably contour the chin, avoiding unnecessary pressure or irritation.
- Safety & Durable: The food grade silicone is BPA free,and makes your baby safe to use.
Pros:
- Super lightweight, for smaller babies and newborns.
- Symmetrical nipple shape makes the pacifier more natural to baby.
- Baby’s skin can breathe easy with the ergonomic shield design.
- Not treated with BPA or any similar chemicals. Contains only UV-stabilizers and antioxidants in the plastic compound, which both are toxic-free materials.
- Available in relaxing tones and convenient 4-pack.
- Easy to clean and sterilize.
Cons:
- Also, some babies may want a nipple that feels a bit more textured, or natural.
- No glow in the dark for nighttime use.
The Tommee Tippee Ultra-Light Silicone Pacifier is one of the best baby pacifiers for breastfed babies due to its perfect combination of comfort, safety, and convenience. Its lightweight construction is best pacifier for breastfed newborn, and the symmetrical shape is designed to promote healthy sucking habits without interfering with the natural development of your baby’s teeth and gums as they suck. Baby is asleep, baby is soothed, baby can relax on-the-go – yay!
8. Chicco PhysioForma Luxe Pacifier 0-6 Months, 2-Pack, Blush.
When it comes to finding the best pacifier for breastfed babies, the factors of comfort, safety, and healthy oral development are key. The Chicco PhysioForma Luxe Silicone Pacifier is expertly developed with leading pediatricians and orthodontists so you can comfort your baby with confidence, even at night. The satiny-smooth silicone and stylish design make it both functional and fashionable for everyday use.
Key Features:
- Helps with Healthy Breathing: Unique PhysioForma shape designed by our orthodontic specialist to support babies in developing proper tongue muscles and improving ventilation.
- Medical-Expert Tested: Developed in partnership with neonatologists, pediatricians, and orthodontists to support a healthy development for baby.
- Silicone Nipple with Satiny Texture: So it feels more like your baby’s skin, and stays in baby’s mouth longer!
- Textured Shield & Handle – to help soothe teething discomfort and provide baby with a soft touch to hold.
- BPA & Latex Free: Baby-safe, high quality material is used in every product.
- Usable Sterilizing Case: Becomes transitional and easy to use on-the-go storage and sanitary way to keep pacifiers clean.
Pros:
- Supports the development of oral motor skills and breathing regulation.
- Ultra-soft silicone nipple has a natural feel for baby and is ideal for breastfed babies.
- Trendy design with textured surface for teething relief.
- Packaging may vary with reusable case for sterilization and storage.
- Clinically proven and pediatrician recommended.
- BPA and latex free for peace of mind.
Cons:
- Limited colors available .
- A little more expensive than most pacifiers.
One of the best pacifier for breastfed newborns, the Chicco PhysioForma Luxe Silicone Pacifier is unparalleled in the world of pacifiers. Featuring a design that promotes soothing and healthy oral development. Made with input from healthcare practitioners, and with thoughtful features like textured shields and a sterilizing case. It’s a great pick for new parents who want to find comfort and confidence in a pacifier.
9. Ryan & Rose Cutie PAT ALL-IN-ONE Pacifier and Teether (2-in-1) Starter Kit (Neutral).
If you’re in need of a multitasking,nontoxic solution that will both calm your baby and offer relief from teething, the Ryan & Rose Cutie PAT Silicone Pacifier Teether is worth considering as one of the best pacifier for breastfed baby. This 2 in 1 product is both a pacifier and teether, so it is a great value for your money as it is so helpful for newborns and growing infants exploring oral development.
Key Features:
- 2 in 1 Function: One side is a pacifier and one side is a teether to massage and soothe sore gums.
- Premium Silicone: Food-grade silicone, offering a soft, plush, and non-toxic surface without any traces of phthalate, latex, or PVC.
- Single-Mould Construction: Body without splices for increased hygiene and security.
- Big Round Shield: Reduces choking/ gagging and provides extra teeth pressure on the tongue side of the teether.
- Breathable & Easy to Grasp: Ventilation holes when used, teether handle is easy for little hands to hold.
Pros:
- Pacifier and Teether moistens instantly so you can use it anywhere, anytime.
- Advanced medical-grade silicone, non-toxic and safe materials.
- Nuby’s Pur Ice Bite Soother Ring Teether is a product that is ideal for the front teeth and reduces the risk of baby’s choking on their food.
- One piece design is hygienic and easy to clean.
- It’s all gender-neutral stylish colors that also makes it an ideal gift possible option.
Cons:
- When To Skip Your baby is very small at birth_Material may seem a bit too thick and bulky for such small babies.
- Not offered in glow-in-the-dark or various textures.
The Ryan & Rose Cutie PAT Silicone Pacifier Teether is just a top pick among the best pacifier for breastfed newborn for a good reason. With high quality materials, dual purpose design and a cute baby friendly handle in it. It is a hit for the moms and dads of today who seek function and look in one! The perfect way to sooth fussy newborns and even fussy toddlers, this pacifier and teether in one is a must-have on your baby gear list.
10. Philips Avent Soothie 0-3 Months Count 1 Green Pacifiers (4 Pack).
As far as comfort, safety and hospital-grade quality go, the Philips Avent Soothie is among the best pacifiers for breastfed babies that you’ll find. It’s the pacifier choice of hospitals and NICUs across the country and experts agree that it is an ideal soother for newborns, most especially those who are breastfed.
Key Features:
- Hospital-TRUSTED Design: Distributed in hospitals nationwide, used/ trusted by pediatricians, medical professionals to calm and soothe newborns.
- Orthodontic & Symmetrical The Orthodontic nipple is symmetrical which makes it taste more natural and to fit in baby’s mouth easier.
- 100% Medical-Grade Silicone: Created with soft, flexible BPA free and latex free silicone that’s gentle on baby’s delicate new gums.
- Finger-Held Design: The nipple is specially designed to be finger-held to enable the baby to simulate the sensation of breastfeeding.
- Snuggle-Compatible: Dr. Brown’s Lovey Pacifier & Teether Holder works with most other brand’s soothers, and easily works with the Philips Avent Snuggle plush toy too.
- Easy To Clean: The water resistant design limits liquid from getting into the nozzle;It’s also sterilizer & boil safe.
Pros:
- Trusted and recommended by hospitals throughout the U.S.
- Soft, pliable medical-grade silicone For newborns.Handled by the product packaging - Box.
- Orthodontic shape supports natural oral development.
- Finger-held design promotes connectivity and allows for natural nursing.
- Easy to sterilize and clean.
Cons:
- Perfect for newborns and 0 to 3 months old; not recommended for older babies.
- Doesn’t have glow in the dark appeal for nighttime visibility.
The Philips Avent Soothie Pacifiers are some of the best newborn pacifier for breastfed. Based on their hospital-trusted quality, orthodontic design and breast-like and flexible material. Great for babies 0-3 months, these pacifiers can help soothe a baby as they transition between breast and pacifier. A new parent essential for safety and comfort from day one.
It doesn’t have to be overwhelming to find the best pacifier for your breastfed baby. Whether you want a newborn-friendly model or one that resembles the breast, there’s a model that will meet your baby’s needs. The pacifiers we’ve included below are all parent-loved and made to encourage breastfeeding all while providing comforting relief. Remember to always follow the lead of your baby—and know that the right choice is the one that makes both you and your baby happy and comfortable.
